Food & Wine // 2 min Read

Buttermilk Chess Pie with Vanilla Mascarpone Crème Recipe

Written by Palmetto Bluff

Indulge in the rich and flavorful Buttermilk Chess Pie with Vanilla Mascarpone Crème by following this delicious recipe from Palmetto Bluff Club’s Executive Pastry Chef, Jae Newby. The Buttermilk Chess Pie Filling combines the perfect blend of ingredients, including a hint of orange zest and a splash of buttermilk, resulting in a velvety, baked masterpiece. Top each slice with the luscious Vanilla Mascarpone Crème, and for an extra touch, consider experimenting with diverse pie crusts or adding a sprinkle of orange zest for a delightful and visually appealing dessert experience.

Buttermilk Chess Pie Filling Ingredients

60 Grams of All-Purpose Flour
20 Grams of Cornmeal
2 Grams of Salt
198 Grams of Sugar
142 Grams of Butter
Orange Zest
Vanilla Bean
4 Eggs
284 Grams of Buttermilk

Instructions

1.Whisk together flour (reserving a little), salt, and cornmeal.
2.Cream butter, sugar, orange zest, and the seeds from the vanilla bean.
3.Add eggs one at a time, mixing well after each addition.
4.Gradually add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients.
5.Slowly incorporate the buttermilk into the batter.
6.Pour the batter into a pre-baked 9” pie shell.
7.Bake at 325°F for 50-60 minutes or until the center is set.

Mascarpone Crème Ingredients

908 Grams of Heavy Cream
454 Grams of Mascarpone
150 Grams of Sugar
10 Grams of Vanilla Bean Paste

Instructions

1.In a separate bowl, whip together heavy cream, mascarpone, sugar, and vanilla bean paste until medium peaks form.

Assembly

Once the Buttermilk Chess Pie is baked and cooled, cut it into 8 equal slices. Serve each slice with a generous dollop of Vanilla Mascarpone Crème. For a decorative touch, sprinkle some additional orange zest on top of the Vanilla Mascarpone Crème. Experiment with different pie crusts, such as a graham cracker or chocolate crust, to add variety to your dessert.

Club Life
The Cottage Arrives at Anson Point

After opening its doors in August, The Cottage at Anson Point, has quickly become a favorite among Golf Members looking to linger before (or after) hitting the fairway. Tucked into the trees near Anson Point’s 18th hole, The Cottage feels both refined a...

Sep 2026

Conservation
Beyond the Bluff: A Costa Rica Nature Adventure

Photos courtesy of Carlos Chacón and Patrick O’Brien The Palmetto Bluff Conservancy creates opportunities for Members and Conservancy supporters to deepen their connection to the natural world, both within the Bluff and beyond. In October 2027, that spirit ...

Sep 2026

Club Life
Fall at The Farm: New Plantings and New Plans

A new season is taking shape at The Farm, where fall planting is underway and plans are progressing for expanded growing space in the months ahead. Farm Manager Shane Rahn and his team began planting for the fall season in September, starting with 320 squas...

Sep 2026

Culture
See the Bluff Through an Artist’s Eyes: Raven Roxanne at Palmetto Bluff

This October, Charleston-based abstract impressionist painter Raven Roxanne comes to Palmetto Bluff for two days of art, nature, and creative exploration inspired by the Lowcountry landscape.Known for her expressive use of color, texture, and movement, Raven f...

Sep 2026

Artist in Residence
Material Memory

Photographs & Story by Hailey Wist As the November Artist in Residence with The Arts Initiative at Palmetto Bluff, Arun Drummond showcased a practice that balances form and cultural memory, emphasizing how portraiture can both honor and illuminate. ...

Sep 2026
palmetto bluff conservancy

Conservation
A New Season with the Palmetto Bluff Conservancy

The Palmetto Bluff Conservancy: Stewarding The Land Members Love For Members of the Palmetto Bluff Club, fall presents new ways to explore the community’s 20,000 acres and learn why the land is so beloved. Members can spend a Tuesday morning on a boat with a...

Aug 2026
fall in south carolina

Culture
Fall in Palmetto Bluff: A Season to Celebrate

Fall in South Carolina Settles into Palmetto Bluff While most of the South Carolina coast goes quiet after Labor Day, Palmetto Bluff stays energized and active. The Farmers Market returns, FLOW Gallery welcomes new Artists in Residence, and the Palmetto Bluff...

Aug 2026
buying a second home

Real Estate
Buying a Second Home in the Lowcountry: What to Know Before You Search

How to Buy a Second Home at Palmetto Bluff Families buying a second home in the Lowcountry often begin their search focusing on the house: square footage, bedroom count, proximity to water. While those details are important, the true measure of value is how o...

Aug 2026

Club Life
Serving Up News from Wilson Lawn & Racquet

Wilson Lawn & Racquet continues to elevate the member experience at Palmetto Bluff, with new talent, fresh programming, and memorable ways to enjoy time on the courts and lawns. From an accomplished new pickleball professional to the Club’s first croquet l...

Aug 2026

Real Estate
A Neighborhood With Boutique Hotel Service, Every Day

Tucked between Hilton Head and Savannah, Palmetto Bluff is one of the Lowcountry’s most extraordinary places—and for years, guests have discovered it through a stay at Montage Palmetto Bluff.  It’s a place that never leaves you, and it’s easy to understand ...

Aug 2026

CURIOUS ABOUT LIFE AT THE BLUFF?

Sign up for our newsletter

LIVE
Community Villages
Experience
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
Events
Conserve
About Us