Food & Wine // 1 min Read

Nutter Butter Pie

Written by Palmetto Bluff

They say that happiness is homemade. And homemade pie? Well, it just doesn’t get better than that.

Chef Anthony DiBernardo from Swig & Swine in Charleston, Mount Pleasant, and Summerville, South Carolina, shares his recipe for Nutter Butter Pie.

A take on his mother’s recipes that he loved growing up, this deliciously nostalgic treat makes every bit of sense to serve for breakfast as it does dessert, utilizing peanut butter, cream cheese, whipped cream, and, what other than, Nutter Butter cookies.

RECIPE:
1 lb. peanut butter
1 lb. cream cheese frosting
1 tsp cream of tartar
1 pint heavy whipping cream
2 tbsp. powdered sugar
1 9-inch pie shell par, baked
Nutter Butter cookies for garnish and snacking

DIRECTIONS:
1. Whip heavy cream, powdered sugar, and cream of tartar to stiff peaks and set aside.

2. Combine peanut butter and cream cheese frosting until incorporated.

3. Fold in whipped cream.

4. Fill pie shell. Crumble some of the cookies and sprinkle over top and garnish with some of the whole cookies.

Photo courtesy of Jonathan Boncek.

Club Life
A New Year, A Fresh Beginning

Before you let your New Year’s resolutions quietly fade, remember this: there are still eleven months ahead. Plenty of time. Plenty of possibilities. This year offers a different approach—one inspired by connection and support. At Palmetto Bluff, you’re sur...

Jan 2026

Club Life
Anson Point In Action

The newest golf experience at Palmetto Bluff is already drawing rave reviews. As the third pillar of golf experience at Palmetto Bluff, Anson Point brings with it a certain lofty set of expectations. After all, it’s hard to follow something like May River G...

Jan 2026

Club Life
Anson Point: Watch A Legend Come To Life

“It's the thrill of being involved in the creation, and it’s the gratification of watching that creation evolve in the manner which you’d hoped”.Bill Coore, Coore & Crenshaw Golf Course Architectshttps://vimeo.com/1155713833?share=copy&fl=sv&fe=c...

Jan 2026

Architecture & Design
Palette Shift

From punchy pastels to saturated jewel tones, color is breaking free of its neutral confines. In these artful Lowcountry homes, design becomes a joyful expression of personality and place.Story by Barry Kaufman / Photographs by Kelli Boyd and Nicole CohenInter...

Jan 2026

Culture
Chef Beth’s Southern Sausage & Sage Stuffing

Warm, fragrant, and deeply comforting, Chef Beth’s Southern Sausage & Sage Stuffing is a holiday classic that brings together rich pork sausage, fresh herbs, and toasted bread for the ultimate savory side dish. Studded with green apples and aromatic vegeta...

Dec 2025

Conservation
Naturally Festive: Palmetto Bluff’s Native Pines and Berries

As December settles over Palmetto Bluff, it brings softer light, cooler mornings, and the natural beauty of native evergreens and winter berries that define the Lowcountry landscape. Palmetto Bluff Conservancy’s Education and Outreach Manager, Aaron Palmieri, ...

Dec 2025

Club Life
2025: A Year of New Beginnings and Continued Discovery

In 2025, Palmetto Bluff welcomed new neighbors and old friends, groundbreakings, and long-awaited openings. From inspired Club gatherings and elevated programming to the creation of our latest golf course, the year was defined by connection and excitement for ...

Dec 2025

Real Estate
Three Homes With Views to Elevate Mind & Mood

There is something serene about waking up to shimmering water, the stillness of the woods, or the sweep of marsh and sky right outside your window. Even without stepping outside, science shows that simply seeing nature from home can meaningfully improve mental...

Dec 2025
Palmetto bluff homes for sale

Real Estate
The Top 8 Benefits of Building on a Homesite

The Ultimate Choice: Building vs Buying a Home in Palmetto Bluff  For those searching for  Palmetto Bluff homes for sale, this common question often arises: Should you choose an existing residence, or embrace the opportunity to build your own? While a complet...

Nov 2025
south carolina winter

Culture
How to Spend a Winter Day in the Lowcountry

A Complete Guide to South Carolina Winter at Palmetto Bluff  South Carolina's winter is unlike any other on the East Coast. While many travelers search for “South Carolina winter” expecting cooler temperatures and limited outdoor options, the Lowcountry revea...

Nov 2025

CURIOUS ABOUT LIFE AT THE BLUFF?

Sign up for our newsletter

LIVE
Community Villages
Experience
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
Events
Conserve
About Us